Assimilation or adaptation? What do you think?

Think Immigration

How do you define assimilation?

By  On April 23, 2013 · 2 Comments
In the past week, the discussion of the immigration reform bill has been colored by the bombing in Boston allegedly perpetrated by two immigrants to the United States.  The horror and confusion surrounding that act has fed opponents of immigration reform to feel even more justified in their resistance. Of particular interest, from a rhetorical perspective, is the discussion of a supposed lack of assimilation among recent immigrant groups and a call by conservative commentators for “patriotic assimilation.”

Last Friday, on her talk show, conservative commentator Laura Ingraham lamented the fact that we cannot evaluate immigrants on their level of assimilation because it is politically incorrect: “So we can say someone is potentially unstable who’s an American citizen, but if someone is potentially not assimilating as a foreigner then we can’t raise any issues about that.”

John O’Sullivan, of the National Review Online, also worried about assimilation – specifically “patriotic assimilation,” a term coined by John Fonte of the Hudson institute. Fonte provides this definition of “patriotic assimilation.” “By patriotic assimilation I mean that immigrants essentially adopt American civic values and the American heritage as their own. “

Sociologists Richard Alba and Victor Nee reject a more dated definition of assimilation, implied in Fonte’s work. That definition, by Milton Gordon, found “middle-class cultural patterns of, largely, white Protestant, and Anglo-Saxon origins” as the marker of “over-all American culture.”

Alba and Nee argue for a new definition of assimilation that recognizes a reciprocal nature to the process. They assert:

Assimilation, as a form of ethnic change, may occur through changes taking place in groups on both sides of the boundary. . . We define assimilation as the decline of an ethnic distinction and its corollary cultural and social differences. . . Individuals’ ethnic origins become less and less relevant in relation to the members of another ethnic group. . . and individuals on both sides of the boundary see themselves more and more as alike. . .

How do you define assimilation?

Read more: http://thinkimmigration.org/2013/04/23/immigration-reform-and-the-notion-of-assimilation/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s